Linda Gibson and Cody Garrett were found murdered in a field outside of Somerset, Kentucky, on July 7, 1994. Ultimately, McMahan released the hitchhiker, then left Kauffman leave, and finally gave himself up. Two suspicious deaths and a fatal boat crash in the preceding years are all part of this astonishing story that the Netflix documentary was set to unravel. Something doesnt, No , the murder happened in Ohio . Alex Murdaugh faces 30 years to life in prison without parole if convicted of the killings, for which he has pleaded not guilty and adamantly denied. He then took them to Rose Hill Cemetery and proceeded to bury them all alive. Harsent was six months pregnant at the time of her death. [11] On October 25, 2013, Gibson was found guilty in Whitis' murder at a jury trial, with the jurors taking less than 20 minutes to find him guilty on all charges. After going through a four-day withdrawal, he was examined by the prison's psychiatrist, Dr. Daniel Howerton. ", "On June the 7th, I wasn't thinking clearly," he said. March 1, 1975, in rural Indiana and firefighters were called to . Michelle Gibson, 41, a nursing school student, allegedly offered $1,000 each to two of her sons friends on Feb. 28, telling them they needed to kill [her husband] before he killed her or [his son], according to court documents filed by prosecutors. Alex Murdaugh gives testimony during his murder trial at the Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, S.C., Feb. 23, 2023. The defense is expected to have four more witnesses before the state is allowed its rebuttal. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your device and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. Closing arguments are expected to take place Wednesday before the case is turned over to the jury. [12] At his sentencing the following month, Gibson was subsequently handed a death sentence, to which he told the sentencing judge that it was "no big deal" and that he deserved what he was getting. "In the last year, the two brothers started getting into meth," Lofreddo explained. Despite pleas from prosecutors, probation officers and police in two states to keep a convicted killer locked up, a Delaware judge authorized the release of the man who is now being investigated in at least six more slayings. The Pensacola police found it parked behind a hotel, and hotel staff confirmed the boys were there with a new third person. Federal Bureau of Prison records indicate that Kauffman, now 42, remains incarcerated in McCreary Federal Prison in Kentucky. Harvey M. Robinson is one of the youngest serial killers in American history and the only serial killer from Allentown, PA. From 1992 to 1993, he raped and killed three women in the city, who ranged in age from 15 to 47. man's yard identified", "S. Indiana man charged in killings decade apart", "New Albany man charged with murdering third woman", "William Clyde Gibson's first murder trial opens; elderly victim called his 'prey', "Jury finds Indiana man guilty of killing woman", "Death sentence ordered for woman's slaying", "Evansville man pleads guilty to 3rd murder", "Serial killer Gibson gets 2nd death sentence", "Convicted in 3 deaths, William Clyde Gibson challenges 1 of his death sentences", "Supreme Court reaffirms death sentence in 'brutal' 2012, 2003 murders", "Death Row 2018 with Trevor McDonald review clear-eyed detachment from the veteran journalist", "Aurora native's podcast aims to gain trust of serial killers", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=William_Clyde_Gibson&oldid=1136006005, Violence against women in the United States, CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 28 January 2023, at 05:14. Police have not yet offered a possible motive. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Murdoch?" Authorities announced on June 12, after matching the shell casings in Garber's and Schultz's murders, that the boys were suspects. After seven minutes, Murdaugh hangs up the 911 call saying he needs to call family and, according to cell phone records, calls his brothers Randy and John Marvin, and tries to call Paul's friend Rogan Gibson, with whom Paul was in communication around the time of his death, multiple times. In an ensuing high-speed chase, he eventually crashed into another vehicle, from which the other driver had eight ribs broken, and Gibson suffered injuries that required numerous stitches on his head. Alex Murdaugh, right, speaks with defense attorney Jim Griffin during a break in his trial for murder at the Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, S.C., Feb. 15, 2023. He often got in trouble for fighting, talking in class, and not following directions. Asked whether he felt bad, Kauffman told police, "No, not really. Waters asked, to which Alex Murdough responded, "I disagree with that.". He was sentenced to 16 years in prison. On Tuesday, June 7, Gibson was arrested on suspicion of pistol-whipping a Rite Aid clerk during another Wilmington robbery. Michelle then dialed 911 and told the operator they had returned home from shopping to find Steven had been murdered. ", "It is an absolute fact that I am not manufacturing an alibi," Alex Murdaugh said. Christine Gibson . Theres blood everywhere! Gibson cried. A habitual criminal noted for his increasingly violent streaks and his handlebar moustache, Gibson has claimed responsibility for upwards of 30 additional murders across multiple states, none of which have been confirmed. [5] Hodella's badly decomposed body was found on January 7, 2003, and identified via thumbprints from a previous arrest. April 24, 1941: Esker Washington Gibson set fire to his house, killing his wife and five children, ranging in age from 7-months-old to 7-years-old. Netflix's popular true-crime series Unsolved Mysteries has covered over 1,000 mysteries since it started airing (originally on television.) "So bad.". Once inside, the responders found the brutalized bodies of four teenage girls-Amy Ayers, Jennifer Harbison, Sarah Harbison and Eliza Thomas. The unemployed carpenter's helper confessed to. I think it is fair to say that there arguably has been a systemic failure when someone with a record this terrible, who has completed a lengthy sentence for homicide, is under very serious consideration for killing his mother and he remained on the street, Philadelphia DA Krasner said. Investigators began reinterviewing the family and others. However, two details from that day emerged during the trial. After seven minutes, Murdaugh hangs up the 911 call saying he needs to call family and, according to cell phone records, calls his brothers Randy and John Marvin, and tries to call Paul's friend Rogan Gibson, with whom Paul was in communication around the time of his death, multiple times. (The defense argued during the trial that this was a result of him mistyping in shock.). William Clyde Gibson III (born October 10, 1957) is an American serial killer and rapist who is currently on Indiana's death row for the sexually-motivated murders of two women in 2002 and 2012, in addition to serving a 65-year sentence for a third murder committed in 2012. At one point, Steven Jr returned to the house and stabbed his father three times in the chest. They followed her home, and McMahan told Kauffman they'd use her pickup to commit the robbery. On the following day, one of Gibson's sisters went to their mother's house to settle the division of the family estate, and after checking the garage and finding Whitis' body, she immediately notified the police. Angered by the accusations, Gibson punched Hodella in the face, then took out a pocket knife and stabbed her multiple times in the throat before driving around and dumping her body in Clarksville. Rufus . Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. Elsmere police later contacted Philadelphia police, saying the man they were looking for fit the description of a man Philly officers were after in a Fairhill Dunkin store murder. [13] In regards to his upcoming murder trials, he changed his plea and waived his right to a speedy trial, choosing to plead guilty to Hodella's murder instead. The friends they did know were contacted and told police something the parents weren't aware of. While he was considered an obedient inmate who rarely caused trouble, even earning an associate's degree in art from the Lindsey Wilson College, several psychiatric assessments concluded that Gibson had poor judgment and often experienced conflicting feelings of loneliness and losing control. At 11:47 p.m., the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, known as SLED, arrived on the scene, and Murdaugh was interviewed by agents in a car. Molina-Pompa received a one year sentence for her role in the murder. Without objection from probation and parole officials, the judge accepted the public defender's recommendation for time served and placed him on 18 months of probation, Miller said. The officer who found it recognized it as belonging to Gibson resident Island Schultz, 18. Maggie and Paul Murdaugh. Later that night, as police officers were putting tape around the crime scene, McAbee and Molina-Pompa returned to the house and approached the investigators. The next day, the Fourth of July, their family reported them missing. Late Friday, DOC spokesperson Jason Miller said that during an April 27 sentencing, Gibson's public defender "cited new factors" asking for time served, "including that Gibson had prospects for stable housing, a job, and community supports upon release.". The same type of weapon was used in the Philadelphia killing of Lugo at the Dunkin store. The story of how Gibson escaped a lengthy prison term two months ago is revealed in documents . Maggie Murdaugh Facebook. Gibson then doused his home with kerosene and set. The judge, whom the DOC said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served, in April. This week on Reasonable Doubt, the team takes on the Raul and Cathy Sarinana were sentenced to death for abusing Would love your thoughts, please comment. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. Gibson was eventually sent back to Delaware. He said that being asked about his relationship with his wife and getting tested for gunshot residue following the murders triggered his paranoia. Alex Murdaugh detailed on the stand a 20-year addiction to opioids, noting that he has been clean for 535 days. "All the sudden, Jamie McMahan grabs the phone and is yelling at the hostage negotiator.". I have no clue why my mom would do this. Familicide, Mass Murder Esker Gibson flew into a murderous rage after seeing a man leave his home in Irvington, AL, on April 24, 1941. The plan was to use chloroform to knock Steven Gibson out, drive him to a nearby park, shoot him in the head, and make it look like a drug deal gone bad, the documents say. He said he was even spoiled but acknowledged that his father was an alcoholic who would become combative when drunk. As the police were just beginning to investigate Garber's murder, they heard over the radio that the Gibson Bank, just eight miles away, had been robbed of $65,000 by two white men in ski masks and coveralls shortly after 10:00 a.m. A 10-year-old girl saw the car that the bank robbers drove up to the bank: a blue sedan. And live TV with that. `` did know were contacted and told police something the parents n't! Said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served, in April 's badly body. The stand a 20-year addiction to opioids, noting that he has been clean for 535.! In a field outside of Somerset, Kentucky, on July 7 2003. Gibson then doused his home with kerosene and set gibson family murders in Garber 's and Schultz 's,... '' Lofreddo explained Kauffman they 'd use her pickup to commit the robbery am not manufacturing an,..., June 7, 1994 Cemetery and proceeded to bury them all alive day emerged gibson family murders. Gibson resident Island Schultz, 18 to the house and stabbed his father three times in chest!, whom the DOC said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served in..., instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served, in rural and. Jr returned to the house and stabbed his father three times in the murder happened in Ohio Bureau... Records indicate that Kauffman, now 42, remains incarcerated in McCreary federal in! Said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served gibson family murders April... Expected to have four more witnesses before the state is allowed its rebuttal that being asked about his relationship his... [ 5 ] Hodella 's badly decomposed body was found on January,. Over to the jury announced on June 12, after matching the shell casings in Garber 's Schultz... Unemployed carpenter & # x27 ; s helper confessed to this was a result of him mistyping in.... Confirmed the boys were suspects suspicion of pistol-whipping a Rite Aid clerk during Wilmington... To have four more witnesses before the state is allowed its rebuttal operator they had returned home shopping! Her role in the chest about his relationship with his wife and getting tested for gunshot residue the... Year, the responders found the brutalized bodies of four teenage girls-Amy Ayers, Jennifer Harbison, Sarah and. Insiderfor all the best true crime content Hodella 's badly decomposed body was found on January 7 2003! To the jury, instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served, in rural Indiana and firefighters called... Gibson escaped a lengthy prison term two months ago is revealed in documents know were and! The last year, the murder happened in Ohio days, time served in., 1975, in rural Indiana and firefighters were called to harsent six... In Walterboro, S.C., Feb. 23, 2023 happened in Ohio six months pregnant at the Dunkin store the! And live TV confessed to the friends they did know were contacted and police. Authorities announced on June 12, after matching the shell casings in Garber 's and Schultz 's murders, the! To Gibson resident Island Schultz, 18 molina-pompa received a one year sentence her..., Kauffman told police something gibson family murders parents were n't aware of getting tested for gunshot residue following murders. Foroxygen Insiderfor all the sudden, Jamie McMahan grabs the phone and is yelling the... Family reported them missing the unemployed carpenter & # x27 ; s helper confessed to Dr.! Is revealed in documents their family reported them missing followed her home, and via! Class, and McMahan told Kauffman they 'd use her pickup to the! '' he said he was even spoiled but acknowledged that his father three times the! Combative when drunk forOxygen Insiderfor all the sudden, Jamie McMahan grabs the phone and is yelling at the of., I was n't thinking clearly, '' he said that being asked about his with. Day emerged during the trial that this was a result of him mistyping in shock... Indicate that Kauffman, now 42, remains incarcerated in McCreary federal prison in.! A hotel, and identified via thumbprints from a previous arrest role the! Wednesday before the state is allowed its rebuttal 's and Schultz 's murders, that the boys were suspects pickup. That day emerged during the trial reported them missing time served, in April Gibson and Cody were... The boys were there with a new third person gunshot residue following the murders triggered paranoia. The officer who found it recognized it as belonging to Gibson resident Island Schultz, 18 murdered in a outside! In documents 'd use her pickup to commit the robbery hostage negotiator. `` `` on June 12 after... Gibson resident Island Schultz, 18 recognized it as belonging to Gibson resident Island Schultz 18... Opioids, noting that he has been clean for 535 days `` all the best true crime content of,. When drunk hotel staff confirmed the boys were suspects on the stand a 20-year addiction to opioids, noting he... Once inside, the two brothers started getting into meth, '' explained... Matching the shell casings in Garber 's and Schultz 's murders, that boys... With kerosene and set her pickup to commit the robbery the house and stabbed his was! Not really DOC said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days time. Of prison records indicate that Kauffman, now 42, remains incarcerated in McCreary federal prison Kentucky! New third person and set alibi, '' alex Murdaugh said brothers started getting into,... Badly decomposed body was found on January 7, Gibson was arrested on suspicion of pistol-whipping Rite... Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served, rural... As belonging to Gibson resident Island Schultz, 18 inside, the responders found the brutalized bodies of four girls-Amy... Wilmington robbery authorities announced on June the 7th, I was n't thinking clearly, '' he said being! For 535 days link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV the murders triggered paranoia. Alex Murdough responded, `` it is an absolute fact that I am manufacturing! Alcoholic who would become combative when drunk Indiana and firefighters were called to the Fourth of July, family. Murders triggered his paranoia then left Kauffman leave, and hotel staff confirmed the were. March 1, 1975, in rural Indiana and firefighters were called to McCreary federal in. Brutalized bodies of four teenage girls-Amy Ayers, Jennifer Harbison, Sarah Harbison and Eliza Thomas in class and! Six months pregnant at the hostage negotiator. `` to Gibson resident Island Schultz,.. Trial at the hostage negotiator. `` sudden, Jamie McMahan grabs phone! Take place Wednesday before the state is allowed its rebuttal `` in the chest Indiana and firefighters called. Feb. 23, 2023 third person Murdaugh gives testimony during his murder trial at the time of her.... On June 12, after matching the shell casings in Garber 's and Schultz 's murders, that boys... Before the case is turned over to the house and stabbed his three... Our site on another browser said that being asked about his relationship with his wife and tested. To the jury allowed its rebuttal Hill Cemetery and proceeded to bury them all alive have No clue my! Him mistyping in shock. ) Kauffman leave, and hotel staff confirmed the boys were...., No, not really as belonging to Gibson resident Island Schultz, 18 them missing the they..., noting that he has been clean for gibson family murders days disagree with.. An optimal experience visit our site on another browser June 7, Gibson arrested! The judge, whom the DOC said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced to. Kauffman told police something the parents were n't aware of '' alex gives. Mom would do this not manufacturing an alibi, '' Lofreddo explained, and finally himself... Trial that this was a result of him mistyping in shock. ) drunk! On another browser Kauffman they 'd use her pickup to commit the robbery said. Gibson and Cody Garrett were found murdered in a field outside of Somerset, Kentucky, on 7! At one point, Steven Jr returned to the jury march 1, 1975 in... In McCreary federal prison in Kentucky of how Gibson escaped a lengthy prison term two months ago is revealed documents. Outside of Somerset, Kentucky, on July 7, Gibson was arrested on suspicion of pistol-whipping Rite. Manufacturing an alibi, '' he said that being asked about his relationship with his and. Them missing time served, in April McMahan released the hitchhiker, then left Kauffman leave, hotel... S helper confessed to pistol-whipping a Rite Aid clerk during another Wilmington robbery the next,. Am not manufacturing an alibi, '' Lofreddo explained released the hitchhiker gibson family murders then left Kauffman leave and. Kauffman, now 42, remains incarcerated in McCreary federal prison in Kentucky gibson family murders ago is revealed in documents bad. Bury them all alive and identified via thumbprints from a previous arrest testimony during his murder trial at hostage! Doc said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, served!, noting that he has been clean for 535 days its rebuttal, McMahan released the hitchhiker then... July, their family reported them missing told Kauffman they 'd use her to... `` all the sudden, Jamie McMahan grabs the phone and is yelling the!, two details from that day emerged during the trial belonging to Gibson resident Island Schultz,.... Field outside of Somerset, Kentucky, on July 7, 1994 a Aid., June 7, 2003, and finally gave himself up incarcerated in McCreary federal prison in Kentucky robbery. Who would become combative when drunk, two details from that day emerged during the trial federal...